Confusion or Fairness in the Field? Rejections in the Ultimatum Game under the Strategy Method.

Donna L. Bahry

Department of Political Science
Penn State University
dbahry@psu.edu

Rick K. Wilson

Department of Political Science
Rice University
Houston, TX
rkw@rice.edu
 

Abstract


Field experiments conducted in the Russian Republics of Tatarstan and Sakha showed that the proposers in the "ultimatum game" almost invariable made offers that split a day's wage at 50/50. These experiments were conducted in a variety of settings, from small isolated villages to large urban areas. While the consistency in proposer behavior seemed odd, it was not given the expectations of the responders. Using the strategy method to elicit a profile of rejections, we find that responders invoke an exceedingly strong norm of a 50/50 split or nothing at all. This paper focuses on the profile of rejections, and combines the experimental data with data drawn from an extensive face-to-face attitudinal survey conducted on the same subjects six weeks prior to participating in the experiment.